"It Came From The Moon" by Sun Valley Gun Club

Song: It Came From the Moon
Artist: Sun Valley Gun Club
Album: Sun Valley Gun Club
Also try:  Pinegrove? Spoon? Yeah, Spoon. maybe the National?
Commentary: I love when you forget about a band that you like long enough for them to put out new music. (new album out this year!) The self-titled 1st album was good though.

Version: